How journalism works, Piketty edition

Political Scrapbook:

23 May 2014: Financial Times claim that their exposure of errors in Thomas Piketty’s 577-page analysis of inequality, Capital in the 21st Century, strikes a blow against its “central theme”:

“The central theme of Prof Piketty’s work is that wealth inequalities are heading back up to levels last seen before the first world war. The investigation undercuts this claim, indicating there is little evidence in Prof Piketty’s original sources to bear out the thesis that an increasing share of total wealth is held by the richest few.

11 November 2014: Financial Times: Thomas Piketty wins the £30,000 Financial Times and McKinsey business book of the year award:

“The FT has in the past questioned some of the French economist’s research for Capital, but the book has provoked a fierce debate about growing inequality and the means to tackle it. “While not everyone agreed on the policy prescriptions, we recognised the quality of the scholarship,” [FT editor] Mr Barber said on behalf of the judges.